Insomnia Cookies Menu with Prices (2026 Update): Full Flavor List + Costs
In 2026, Insomnia Cookies remains one of the most popular late-night dessert delivery services across the U.S., offering a wide variety of fresh-baked cookies, brownies, ice cream, and catering boxes. Their menu is now broader than ever, catering to classic cookie fans, vegan eaters, gluten-free customers, and late-night snackers who want their treats warm, fast, and customizable.
If you’re new to Insomnia or planning your next order, this guide provides a complete breakdown of the full Insomnia Cookies menu with updated prices, portion options, and flavor descriptions. From single cookies to massive 100-cookie catering packs, you’ll know exactly what’s available — and what it costs.
Cookie Categories in 2026
The Insomnia Cookies menu is organized into the following categories:
- Classic Cookies
- Deluxe Cookies
- Brownies & Blondies
- Cookie ‘Wiches (Ice Cream Sandwiches)
- Ice Cream
- Boxes & Combos
- Vegan & Gluten-Free Cookies
- Cookie Cakes
- Catering Packs
Each item can be ordered individually or bundled in custom boxes. Delivery, pickup, and shipping options are available depending on your location.
2026 Insomnia Cookies Pricing Overview
| Item Type | Typical Price Range (USD) | Details |
|---|---|---|
| Classic Cookies (each) | $2.25 – $2.75 | Buy singles or bundle in 6, 12, 18 packs |
| Deluxe Cookies (each) | $3.50 – $4.25 | Larger, richer cookies with more mix-ins |
| Vegan Cookies (each) | $2.50 – $3.00 | Available in select classic flavors |
| Gluten-Free Cookie | $3.00 – $3.50 | Limited to chocolate chip flavor |
| Brownies/Blondies | $3.50 – $4.25 | Includes Brookies, Blondies, and Brownie Squares |
| Cookie ‘Wiches | $6.50 – $8.00 | Ice cream sandwiches with classic/deluxe cookies |
| Ice Cream (cup or pint) | $3.50 (cup), $7.50 (pint) | Many flavors; also available on cookies/brownies |
| Combo Boxes (6–24 pcs) | $12.00 – $36.00 | Classic or deluxe mix packs |
| Cookie Cakes (large) | $22.00 – $32.00 | Customizable, perfect for parties |
| Catering Packs (50–100 pcs) | $65.00 – $110.00 | Great for offices, events, or birthdays |
💡 Note: Prices may vary slightly by location. Delivery fees and tax are applied at checkout.
What Makes the 2026 Menu Unique?
Insomnia has evolved beyond just chocolate chip cookies. Their 2026 menu includes:
- Rotating seasonal flavors like Red Velvet, Pumpkin Spice, and Peppermint Brownie
- A growing vegan lineup with three full-time flavors
- One gluten-free classic-style cookie made fresh-to-order
- Premium Deluxe Cookies with ingredients like marshmallow, caramel, peanut butter cups, and more
- Custom packaging for cookie boxes, gifting, and corporate orders
Most locations now offer a mix-and-match feature during online checkout. That means you can combine classic and deluxe cookies, add ice cream scoops, or build cookie sandwiches to create a fully personalized dessert box.
Why This Menu Matters for Customers
As food delivery competition increases, customers are looking for clarity, value, and fast fulfillment. The Insomnia Cookies menu with prices is one of the most-searched queries in this niche — especially during late-night hours, holidays, and exam weeks.
Common related searches include:
- insomnia cookies flavors list
- insomnia cookies box prices
- how much is a cookie cake from insomnia
- best insomnia cookie bundle
This blog directly answers those queries while providing updated 2026 pricing — making it a useful reference for both buyers and search engines.
Classic Insomnia Cookies Menu with Prices & Descriptions (2026)
Insomnia’s classic cookies are the foundation of their menu — simple, warm, and nostalgic. In 2026, these cookies remain the most affordable and widely ordered category on the platform. They’re available as singles, part of 6-pack or 12-pack boxes, or as part of catering orders and gift sets.
Here is the full list of classic Insomnia Cookies, including descriptions, pricing, and pro tips on flavor pairing.
Classic Cookie Menu with Prices
| Flavor Name | Price (Each) | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Chocolate Chunk | $2.25 | The signature cookie loaded with oversized semi-sweet chocolate chunks. Crisp edges, gooey center. |
| Classic with M&M’S® | $2.50 | Buttery cookie dough with colorful candy-coated M&M’s® pieces — sweet, soft, and playful. |
| Oatmeal Raisin | $2.25 | A chewy, cinnamon-scented cookie with plump raisins and hearty oats — a classic comfort treat. |
| Double Chocolate Chunk | $2.50 | Rich cocoa cookie dough with double the chocolate chunks for serious chocolate lovers. |
| Double Chocolate Mint | $2.50 | Minty chocolate dough with chocolate chips — similar to a Thin Mint, but softer and chewier. |
| Peanut Butter Chip | $2.25 | Sweet peanut butter cookie base with melting peanut butter chips in every bite. |
| White Chocolate Macadamia | $2.50 | Creamy white chocolate chunks with buttery macadamia nuts — a rich, tropical-inspired favorite. |
| Snickerdoodle | $2.25 | A cinnamon sugar classic with soft texture and crisp edges — subtly sweet and spiced. |
| Sugar | $2.25 | A soft-baked, buttery sugar cookie — ideal for custom frosting, stacking, or simple enjoyment. |
Vegan Classic Cookie Options (Available Year-Round)
| Flavor Name | Price (Each) | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Vegan Chocolate Chunk | $2.75 | Plant-based version of the classic chocolate chunk cookie, made with vegan butter and no dairy. |
| Vegan Double Chocolate | $2.75 | Cocoa-rich vegan cookie with dark chocolate chunks — soft, indulgent, and dairy-free. |
| Vegan Birthday Cake | $2.75 | Sprinkle-filled vanilla vegan cookie with soft texture and festive flavor. |
📌 Note: Vegan cookies are clearly labeled during checkout and are available at most locations, though availability may vary.
How to Order Classic Cookies in 2026
You can order classic cookies in several ways:
- Single cookies: Choose any flavor
- 6-pack box: $13.50 (best for casual sharing)
- 12-pack box: $24.00 (ideal for offices or parties)
- 50-pack catering box: ~$65.00 (mix of classic flavors)
- Build Your Own Box: Mix and match flavors via website or app
Each classic cookie is freshly baked and delivered warm unless you choose pickup or local shipping. The base dough is consistent across most flavors, providing a chewy texture with golden edges.
Deluxe Insomnia Cookies Menu with Prices & Reviews (2026 Update)
Insomnia’s Deluxe Cookies are a premium tier of their menu — larger, thicker, and loaded with indulgent ingredients like caramel, peanut butter cups, and toasted marshmallows. In 2026, they remain some of the best-selling items due to their visual appeal, rich texture, and unique flavor combos.
Priced slightly higher than classic cookies, they offer more value per bite and are often included in combo boxes or paired with ice cream for maximum dessert satisfaction.
Deluxe Cookie Menu with Updated 2026 Prices
| Flavor Name | Price (Each) | Description |
|---|---|---|
| S’mores Deluxe | $4.00 | A graham-infused cookie packed with chocolate chunks and gooey marshmallow bits — rich, chewy, nostalgic. |
| Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup | $4.00 | Thick chocolate dough loaded with chunks of real peanut butter cups — ideal for candy bar lovers. |
| Confetti Deluxe | $3.75 | A soft, cake-like vanilla cookie filled with rainbow sprinkles and white chocolate chips. |
| Salted Caramel Deluxe | $4.00 | Buttery caramel flavor balanced with a hint of sea salt and caramel chips — sweet and savory perfection. |
| Triple Chocolate Deluxe | $4.00 | A dense cookie made with cocoa dough, dark chocolate chips, and milk chocolate chunks. |
| Oatmeal Chocolate Walnut | $3.75 | A hearty oatmeal cookie with semi-sweet chocolate and crunchy walnut pieces — textured and nutty. |
📌 Note: Deluxe cookies are thicker and wider than classic cookies and often weigh over 2x more.
Deluxe Cookie Bundle Pricing (2026)
| Bundle Type | Quantity | Price | Includes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Deluxe 4-Pack | 4 Deluxe | $15.00 | Choice of any deluxe flavors |
| Deluxe + Pint Combo | 6 Cookies + 1 Pint Ice Cream | $18.00 – $20.00 | Mix of deluxe & classic + one full pint of ice cream |
| Super 6 Box | 3 Deluxe + 3 Classic | $14.00 | Balanced half/half box |
💡 You can mix deluxe and classic cookies in most custom boxes using the Insomnia app or website.
Why Choose Deluxe Cookies Over Classic?
Deluxe Cookies aren’t just bigger — they’re made with specialty dough bases and more complex flavor profiles. The texture is usually soft and thick in the center, with slight crisping on the outer edges. These cookies appeal to more mature palates and are ideal for:
- Birthday and holiday gifting
- Late-night indulgence orders
- Instagram-worthy dessert platters
- Pairing with pints or deluxe ice cream sandwiches
They’re especially popular in university towns, birthdays, corporate celebrations, and foodie TikTok reviews.
Top 3 Deluxe Cookie Picks (Editor’s Note)
| Flavor | Why It Stands Out |
|---|---|
| S’mores Deluxe | Most visually appealing, nostalgic flavor, perfect with milk or ice cream |
| Salted Caramel Deluxe | Excellent balance of sweet and salty, with great mouthfeel |
| Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup | Perfect for candy lovers — dense, rich, and melts in your hand |
Deluxe cookies help position Insomnia as more than just a “college delivery service.” They’re gourmet-level treats — affordable, portable, and deeply satisfying.
Ice Cream, Cookie’Wiches & Brownies — Full Menu with 2026 Prices
Primary Keywords: insomnia cookies ice cream, insomnia brownies, cookie’wich prices
LSI Keywords: ice cream sandwich insomnia, brownie brookie insomnia, insomnia pint price, dessert delivery insomnia
Insomnia Cookies doesn’t stop at cookies. In 2026, their dessert menu includes premium ice cream, warm brownies, and their iconic Cookie’Wiches — all available for delivery late into the night. These offerings are designed to complement cookie bundles or stand alone as indulgent desserts.
Whether you’re building a pint-and-cookie combo or grabbing a deluxe brownie on your way home, these items add flavor, variety, and personalization to the Insomnia experience.
🍦 Ice Cream Menu & Prices (2026)
| Item | Price (USD) | Details |
|---|---|---|
| Ice Cream in a Cup | $3.50 | Single scoop of your choice in a paper cup — basic and flexible |
| Ice Cream on Classic Cookie | $5.00 | One scoop served on your favorite classic cookie |
| Ice Cream on Deluxe Cookie | $5.75 | Larger scoop + larger cookie = premium single-serve combo |
| Ice Cream on Brownie | $5.50 | One scoop on a warm brownie — great for fudge lovers |
| Pint (Take-Home) | $7.50 | Choose from multiple signature flavors; resealable and sharable |
Flavors May Include: Chocolate, Vanilla, Mint Chocolate Chip, Birthday Cake, Strawberry, Cookies N Cream, and seasonal specials like Pumpkin Spice.
🍨 Cookie’Wiches (Ice Cream Sandwiches)
| Item | Price | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Cookie’Wich | $6.50 | Two classic cookies with one scoop of ice cream sandwiched in the middle |
| Deluxe Cookie’Wich | $7.75 | Two deluxe cookies + larger scoop — rich, filling, and fully customizable |
Customers can build their Cookie’Wich by choosing any two cookies (same or different) and selecting their preferred ice cream flavor. Toppings are available at select locations.
🍫 Brownies, Brookies, & Blondies — Prices & Descriptions
| Item | Price | Details |
|---|---|---|
| Chocolate Chip Brownie | $3.75 | Dense and chewy brownie with classic chocolate chip infusion |
| Chocolate Chunk Brookie | $4.00 | Half brownie, half cookie — layered for texture and chocolate overload |
| Chocolate Chunk Blondie | $4.00 | Brown sugar blondie with white and milk chocolate chunks — sweet and chewy |
These items are baked fresh and served warm, ideal for solo orders or dessert pairings with milk or ice cream.
🎯 How to Maximize Value with Combos
Many customers ask:
“Is the Cookie’Wich worth the price?”
“Can I add a brownie to my box order?”
“How much is a pint + 6 cookies?”
The answer: Insomnia bundles these treats into custom combos that reduce cost per item. For example:
| Combo | Includes | Price (2026) |
|---|---|---|
| Deluxe 4-pack + Pint | 4 Deluxe Cookies + 1 Ice Cream Pint | ~$18.00 |
| Super 6 | 3 Classic + 3 Deluxe + Optional Ice Cream | ~$14.00 |
| Cookie’Wich + Drink | 1 Sandwich + Milk or Soda | ~$8.25 |
Conclusion: Insomnia Cookies Menu = Custom, Craveable, and Convenient
In 2026, Insomnia Cookies continues to dominate the dessert delivery market by offering:
- A deep flavor catalog (classic, deluxe, vegan, seasonal)
- Transparent pricing and box savings
- Full customization with ice cream, sandwiches, and cakes
- Party and event support with catering trays and cakes
- Nationwide delivery with late-night hours
